Not

Hacker News!

Beta
Home
Jobs
Q&A
Startups
Trends
Users
Live
AI companion for Hacker News

Not

Hacker News!

Beta
Home
Jobs
Q&A
Startups
Trends
Users
Live
AI companion for Hacker News
  1. Home
  2. /Story
  3. /Kids who own smartphones before age 13 have worse mental health outcomes: Study
  1. Home
  2. /Story
  3. /Kids who own smartphones before age 13 have worse mental health outcomes: Study
Nov 22, 2025 at 4:11 PM EST

Kids who own smartphones before age 13 have worse mental health outcomes: Study

donsupreme
48 points
21 comments

Mood

informative

Sentiment

negative

Category

news

Key topics

Smartphones

Mental Health

Children

Discussion Activity

Light discussion

First comment

3h

Peak period

3

Hour 4

Avg / period

1.7

Comment distribution20 data points
Loading chart...

Based on 20 loaded comments

Key moments

  1. 01Story posted

    Nov 22, 2025 at 4:11 PM EST

    1d ago

    Step 01
  2. 02First comment

    Nov 22, 2025 at 7:05 PM EST

    3h after posting

    Step 02
  3. 03Peak activity

    3 comments in Hour 4

    Hottest window of the conversation

    Step 03
  4. 04Latest activity

    Nov 24, 2025 at 12:00 AM EST

    2h ago

    Step 04

Generating AI Summary...

Analyzing up to 500 comments to identify key contributors and discussion patterns

Discussion (21 comments)
Showing 20 comments of 21
thebigspacefuck
1d ago
3 replies
How’s this compare to computer/internet usage? I’ve been chronically online most years since age 7 but didn’t get a smartphone until 22 or so.
BrenBarn
1d ago
1 reply
My anecdotal observations suggest it's pretty different. One thing is you can (and do, if you're a kid) carry it everywhere with you and stare at it all the time. I think the phone UI where each app takes over the whole screen also increases the impact of the worst sorts of apps (like TikTok).
gblargg
1d ago
1 reply
Interesting observation about everything effectively running in full-screen on a smartphone, taking it out of the larger context of whatever else you were doing before that.
jackvalentine
21h ago
Very! I’ll be thinking about that for a while.
kogasa240p
1d ago
1 reply
Personally I'd think its different, smartphone apps usually have tons of dark patterns and are designed to always be with you versus a desktop or even a laptop.
oneshtein
1d ago
1 reply
Remove Google Play, install F-Droid instead with curated list of apps and games.
fylo
10h ago
Curated by who?
techjamie
17h ago
It probably makes a difference that the internet of ~15 years ago was healthier to use than the half-dozen websites that encompass the entire internet for most people today. Attention-optimizing algorithms and infinite scrolling are some of the worst inventions that have come to the internet since the pop-up ad.
dcchambers
1d ago
1 reply
Reading Jonathan Haidt's 'The Anxious Generation' broke me. I have two kids, still far too young for smartphones, but his book and all of the surrounding research has made me DRASTICALLY alter the way I use my own smartphone and will shape the way I treat phones with them.

If you have kids, take the "wait until 8th" pledge: https://www.waituntil8th.org/

No smart phones until after 8th grade.

bigstrat2003
1d ago
Real talk, if I had kids they wouldn't get a smartphone until they turned 18. Kids have no business having smartphones.
chanux
16h ago
1 reply
What purpose does the id parameter doing this URL? The site does not work without it.
AlfeG
15h ago
Because it's id?

I mean slug is not important - id - is. https://abcnews.go.com/GMA/Family/eating-carrots-make-childr...

yooloo
21h ago
or ever
captainkrtek
2h ago
I've struggled throughout my life with anxiety, ADHD, and bouts of depression.

I've done years of therapy, and use some medication to help with my ADHD. I will say though, singlehandedly, the best (and hardest) thing I've had to do is fight my own phone/internet/computer usage.

I grew up with computers and still work professionally with them day to day, but have made a serious effort in the last year to cut down my usage in an extreme manner:

- Using a 'brick' device to control which apps work on my phone, requiring I physically tap my phone to the brick to lock/unlock the restricted mode. This is always on.

- Blocking tons of sites via multiple means (iOS screen time, eero network profiles)

- Turning my iPhone into a very very basic phone: in "bricked" mode, which I will find myself using for continuous days at a time, I can only use: gmail, photos, notes, weather, maps, spotify, telephone, imessage. No news, no internet browsing, no social media.

- I've deleted all social media accounts (except LinkedIn, but this too is blocked on my phone).

From all of this, the initial realization was, "wow, I'm bored..", which is hard at first to sit with as a feeling, when normally my first instinct to that feeling was "let's open some app/youtube/etc." Then you slowly find positive things creeping in to occupy that boredom time: reading, calling friends/family, getting chores done, etc.

thebigspacefuck
1d ago
I wonder how many 5-6 year olds are getting smartphones because parents are divorced and one parent wants to be able to check in on the other, could be something like that is the issue
throwout4110
1d ago
Horrifically terrible data and methodology for even suggesting causal claims. Global Mind Data is literally self report online survey data. You may as well have used political surveys from Fox News and MSNBC
bethekidyouwant
1d ago
Keeping your kids away from screens requires a significant parental effort
elwesties
1d ago
Honestly seems like a proxy for bad parents have sad kids. Makes logical sense to me.
udev4096
1d ago
It really depends. Not all kids are extremely dumb and get hooked by very obvious attempts from evil social networks. I still have hope for future aaron swartzs and linus torvaldss
andai
1d ago
So, I can tell you my reaction when I was 13 and first saw a smartphone. (It must have been late 2007 or 2008.)

You know. Everything's round and cute and colorful. Like candy.

"Oh. This is for retarded people."

Unfortunately I was wrong.

It's actually much worse than that. It's for normal people. But it makes you retarded.

Slowly. You don't even notice it happening.

It eats away... day by day.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-36256-4

1 more comments available on Hacker News

View full discussion on Hacker News
ID: 46018292Type: storyLast synced: 11/23/2025, 12:07:04 AM

Want the full context?

Jump to the original sources

Read the primary article or dive into the live Hacker News thread when you're ready.

Read ArticleView on HN

Not

Hacker News!

AI-observed conversations & context

Daily AI-observed summaries, trends, and audience signals pulled from Hacker News so you can see the conversation before it hits your feed.

LiveBeta

Explore

  • Home
  • Jobs radar
  • Tech pulse
  • Startups
  • Trends

Resources

  • Visit Hacker News
  • HN API
  • Modal cronjobs
  • Meta Llama

Briefings

Inbox recaps on the loudest debates & under-the-radar launches.

Connect

© 2025 Not Hacker News! — independent Hacker News companion.

Not affiliated with Hacker News or Y Combinator. We simply enrich the public API with analytics.