The Rise and Fall of the British Detective Novel (2010)
Posted4 months agoActive3 months ago
historytoday.comOtherstory
calmmixed
Debate
40/100
Detective FictionBritish LiteratureCrime Genre
Key topics
Detective Fiction
British Literature
Crime Genre
The article discusses the rise and fall of the British detective novel, sparking a discussion among commenters about the current state of the genre and recommendations for authors and works.
Snapshot generated from the HN discussion
Discussion Activity
Active discussionFirst comment
1h
Peak period
18
Day 4
Avg / period
4
Comment distribution24 data points
Loading chart...
Based on 24 loaded comments
Key moments
- 01Story posted
Sep 16, 2025 at 1:18 AM EDT
4 months ago
Step 01 - 02First comment
Sep 16, 2025 at 2:19 AM EDT
1h after posting
Step 02 - 03Peak activity
18 comments in Day 4
Hottest window of the conversation
Step 03 - 04Latest activity
Sep 25, 2025 at 10:49 AM EDT
3 months ago
Step 04
Generating AI Summary...
Analyzing up to 500 comments to identify key contributors and discussion patterns
ID: 45258279Type: storyLast synced: 11/20/2025, 1:48:02 PM
Want the full context?
Jump to the original sources
Read the primary article or dive into the live Hacker News thread when you're ready.
Robert Harris comes to mind too.
If the point is that whodunit has moved on, so has almost every other genre.
Released on 2 September 2025, it is the eighth book in the Cormoran Strike series of detective fiction novels, following The Running Grave."
Furthermore, given what's surrounding its author, there's a non-negligible part of the readers community that won't read it, just because of its author. And it can be seen as _risky_ to read anything she publishes. During a party, someone decided to stop talking to me once I told I was currently reading a book in the series (we were discussing our current reading, so I wasn't trying to do anything smart here). On the other hand, I doubt there's people still buying her books just to _own the libs_.
Sure, it helped launching the series, but if there's still thousands people reading it after more than a decade, maybe it's because those people like it. Maybe.
1) In the grand scheme of world literature, JKR’s books are comparative trash. It’s also well-established that the first book was not successful until the real identity of the author was shared.
2) Harry Potter (and all of the related activity) is still hugely popular, despite JKR’s unpleasant views and behaviour related to trans people. Most people in the world aren’t locked into the online zeitgeist.
But like you point out, there's been a zillion other "rises" too. Maybe a more acurate but much longer article would be "the rise and fall and rise and fall and rise [...] of the British detective novel"
The "mystery" was how the detective was going to figure it out.
There's a good piece on that form here: https://mysteriesahoy.com/2019/01/26/five-to-try-inverted-my...
https://www.goodreads.com/series/59006-dr-david-audley-colon...
“Pshaw, my dear fellow, what do the public, the great unobservant public, who could hardly tell a weaver by his tooth or a compositor by his left thumb, care about the finer shades of analysis and deduction! But, indeed, if you are trivial, I cannot blame you, for the days of the great cases are past. Man, or at least criminal man, has lost all enterprise and originality. As to my own little practice, it seems to be degenerating into an agency for recovering lost lead pencils and giving advice to young ladies from boarding-schools.
-- From "The Adventure of the Copper Beeches" in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes.
Every kid should be given a copy of the complete Sherlock Holmes canon (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canon_of_Sherlock_Holmes) This will turn them towards learning and practicing "The Art of Deduction (or Ratiocination according to Edgar Allan Poe)" like nothing else and will directly lead to them understanding the importance of Logic and Science/Mathematics in today's world.
For example, as a kid growing up in 80s India, i read whatever i could get my hands on (eg. Hardy Boys, Nancy Drew, Enid Blyton, Alistair Maclean, Desmond Bagley, Frederick Forsyth etc. etc.) but none of them really made a mark. Then somebody gave me a copy of "The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes" and i was zapped. Here was somebody who focused on reasoning and showed you the steps involved. Of course once you grew-up you realized that much of the "Deductions" were far-fetched/implausible but nevertheless the fire was lit. It directly led to my interest in Science/Mathematics and then a career in Software (much of Holmes' methods are directly applicable to Debugging).
[0] https://github.com/benrutter/wimsey / https://codeberg.org/benrutter/wimsey
[1] https://killerthrillers.net/honkaku-detective-fiction/
Ann Cleeves
Robert Galbraith
Richard Osman
Tim Sullivan
Janice Hallett
Ian Rankin
JR Ellis
Alexander McCall Smith
And those are authors I'm reading because they were featured on some Kindle lists.
This course, which I took a while back, was curiously extremely focused on pulp detective novels. I got the sense that it was a tenured professors hobby or something. Interesting, nonetheless.