Challenge: an Asymmetric Key System That Does Everything
Key topics
We have asymmetric cryptography, but the main systems all have trade-offs:
RSA: You can encrypt/decrypt and sign/verify, but you cannot derive hierarchical public/private keys—every key pair must be generated independently.
ECDSA (elliptic curves): You can sign/verify, and you can derive hierarchical deterministic keys (HD wallets!), but you cannot do encryption/decryption natively.
So here’s the challenge:
Can anyone design an asymmetric key system that can do all five things:
1. Encrypt
2. Decrypt
3. Sign
4. Verify
5. Hierarchical key derivation (master → child public/private keys)
Right now, no single system can do this perfectly. Either you get encryption or hierarchical keys, but not both.
If we could create such a system, it would unify digital identity, secure messaging, and deterministic key management in a single cryptosystem.
I’d love to see ideas, proposals, or even wild theoretical approaches. Has anyone tried combining elliptic-curve deterministic keys with encryption in a clean way?
Oiko
The author proposes a challenge to design an asymmetric key system that can perform encryption, decryption, signing, verification, and hierarchical key derivation, and invites discussion on potential solutions.
Snapshot generated from the HN discussion
Discussion Activity
No activity data yet
We're still syncing comments from Hacker News.
Generating AI Summary...
Analyzing up to 500 comments to identify key contributors and discussion patterns
Want the full context?
Jump to the original sources
Read the primary article or dive into the live Hacker News thread when you're ready.
Discussion hasn't started yet.