The First Photographs of Snowflakes Discover the Groundbreaking Microphotography (2017)

Posted15 days agoActive8 days ago

_____k

91 points

18 comments

openculture.comNewsstory

informativepositive

Debate

0/100

Creative_toolsMaterials ScienceHistory

Key topics

Creative_tools

Materials Science

History

Delving into the fascinating world of snowflakes, a thread discussing the first photographs of these intricate ice crystals heats up with commenters marveling at the impressive images and sharing their own experiences with crystalline formations. As one commenter, thdrtol, explains, the tetrahedral shape of water molecules lays the foundation for snowflakes' six-sided symmetry, with temperature, moisture, and pressure influencing their unique designs. Meanwhile, others debate the thread title, with some finding it misleading, while the author, _____k, clarifies that character limits forced a tweak. The conversation is rounded out by a recommendation to check out a Veritasium video on the subject, adding to the thread's engaging blend of science and wonder.

Snapshot generated from the HN discussion

Discussion Activity

Active discussion

First comment

Peak period

156-168h

Avg / period

Comment distribution18 data points

Loading chart...

Based on 18 loaded comments

Key moments

01Story posted
Dec 18, 2025 at 4:58 PM EST
15 days ago
Step 01
02First comment
Dec 25, 2025 at 9:48 AM EST
7d after posting
Step 02
03Peak activity
13 comments in 156-168h
Hottest window of the conversation
Step 03
04Latest activity
Dec 25, 2025 at 8:10 PM EST
8 days ago
Step 04

Generating AI Summary...

Analyzing up to 500 comments to identify key contributors and discussion patterns

Discussion (18 comments)

Showing 18 comments

HelloUsername

8 days ago

1 reply

(2017)

RobotCaleb

8 days ago

(1885)

deadbabe

8 days ago

2 replies

Are the design of snowflakes a thin slice of some 3D shape defined by a mathematical function?

thdrtol

8 days ago

The tetrahedral shape of the molecules define the 6 sides. I believe that would be a constant.

Temperature, moisture, pressure and maybe more variables are the parameters.

lioeters

8 days ago

A snowflake is a 3D recursive growth algorithm over time. The macroscopic shapes are inherent in an earlier seed of molecular structure and arrangement of other factors by chance and circumstance. As they form while falling through the air, I imagine the crystalline shape grows in three dimensions, stretched by gravity or air resistance. So I'd say their design, at any moment, is a slice of a fourth-dimensional structure-over-time that can be described by a mathematical function, which ends in a wet puddle on the ground.

block_dagger

8 days ago

2 replies

The headline does not match the article title and is currently nonsensical.

_____kAuthor

8 days ago

1 reply

Enforcement of character limit for the header got it place. I did not want to alter it too much either.

nutjob2

8 days ago

1 reply

The article title is written as a title and subtitle, separated by a colon.

So the correct title of the article is 'The First Photographs of Snowflakes'.

_____kAuthor

8 days ago

Oh yes, it looks like I missed the colon during the edit.

tjr

8 days ago

1 reply

I might have said that I didn't realize snowflakes took photographs, but it turns out to be the work of Wilson "Snowflake" Bentley, so I guess in this case, they do.

ryukoposting

8 days ago

I think I see your reading, but I'd add an apostrophe:

The First Photographs of Snowflake's Discover the Groundbreaking Microphotography

i.e. the first photographs on Snowflake's part. Though that still doesn't resolve how a guy's pictures discovered microphotography, rather than the guy himself.

srean

8 days ago

Once I had ended up with beautiful snowflakes and crystalline layers, entirely by accident.

I had been washing a bowl (with an airtight lid) in steaming hot water when I got interrupted. So, I did what everyone does when they cannot find an appropriate place for what they have on their hands.

I slapped the empty steaming bowl shut, put it in the freezer, the nearest thing that looked like a cabinet with a door and promptly forgot about it.

A few weeks later I found that both the bowl and the lid were covered with exquisite layers of crystals. I tried hard to photograph them, just did not come out right.

I kept the crystals for many months.

alhirzel

8 days ago

This reminds me of the following, a story from my personal life. My wife and I both ski, and early in our relationship one of us told the other about the coolest poster ever about snowflakes. We each described it. We were sure we were talking about the same one - the one that graphed how snow changes over temperature and helped explain why it can feel so different. One of us pulled it up, and we realized, well...

[1]: https://vermontsnowflakes.com/cdn/shop/products/Snowflake_Th...

[2]: https://physics.montana.edu/demonstrations/video/1_mechanics...

She was talking about #1 (the work of Bentley made into a collage), and I was talking about #2. It turned out to be a pretty good way of thinking about how imperfect communication is, and how hard it is to get on the same page about things that are even more important when all we have is words.

nephihaha

8 days ago

The snowflake line is from Chuck Palahniuk's book "Fight Club". In it a character tells another one that they are "not a beautiful and unique snowflake" but part of the same "compost heap". The book was satirising soft soap self-help messaging. Snowflakes do melt easily which has aided it in getting its new meaning.

mpalmer

8 days ago

The retitling is a mess

jibal

8 days ago

Love Elinor Merle's snowflake earrings.

opello

8 days ago

Also worth checking out the Veritasium video on snowflakes:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ao2Jfm35XeE

Forgeties79

8 days ago