Tell-Hn: Identity Verification Provider Used by Linkedin Transfers Gov Id to USA
Key topics
Download their Mobile App -> Scan the QR Code -> Download a Partner App -> Upload a picture of my government issued ID + a photo of my face
At least one of their providers are sketch. From what I saw they use (a company called CLEAR and one called PERSONA).CLEAR's privacy policy specifies they may store, process, and transfer personal data in a country other than that in which you live, including the United States. They state compliance with the EU-US Data Privacy Framework, UK Extension to that, and Swiss-US Data Privacy Framework for handling data from EU/UK/Switzerland.
While they describe their security commitments (encryption, controls, etc.), there is no clear public statement specifying which exact countries or data centres they use beyond implying "countries other than that where you live".
At least with CLEAR's data could be stored in the US, or another country EVEN if you’re in Europe.
Potential Data Breaches aside, this is a problem because even under the new EU-US Data Privacy Framework (DPF), fundamental legal issue from Safe Harbor (2000-2015) and Privacy Shield (2016-2020) remains.
- US intelligence laws (notably FISA 702 and Executive Order 12333) still let U.S. agencies collect data from U.S. companies, even if that data belongs to EU citizens.
- The U.S. CLOUD Act (2018) requires U.S. companies to provide data to U.S. law enforcement when legally requested — even if that data is stored in Europe.
- Even if your data is physically stored in Frankfurt or Dublin, if the service is run by a U.S. company, U.S. authorities could compel access.
The author expresses concern over LinkedIn's identity verification process, which involves transferring government-issued IDs to the US, potentially violating EU data protection laws.
Snapshot generated from the HN discussion
Discussion Activity
No activity data yet
We're still syncing comments from Hacker News.
Generating AI Summary...
Analyzing up to 500 comments to identify key contributors and discussion patterns
Want the full context?
Jump to the original sources
Read the primary article or dive into the live Hacker News thread when you're ready.
Discussion hasn't started yet.