Gene Tests Begin in Women's Athletics
Posted4 months agoActive4 months ago
bbc.comResearchstory
controversialmixed
Debate
80/100
Gender Testing in SportsTransgender AthletesGenetic Advantages
Key topics
Gender Testing in Sports
Transgender Athletes
Genetic Advantages
The BBC reports on the introduction of gene tests in women's athletics, sparking debate on the fairness and implications of such tests, particularly for transgender athletes.
Snapshot generated from the HN discussion
Discussion Activity
Light discussionFirst comment
7h
Peak period
3
Day 2
Avg / period
2
Key moments
- 01Story posted
Aug 31, 2025 at 11:21 PM EDT
4 months ago
Step 01 - 02First comment
Sep 1, 2025 at 5:52 AM EDT
7h after posting
Step 02 - 03Peak activity
3 comments in Day 2
Hottest window of the conversation
Step 03 - 04Latest activity
Sep 16, 2025 at 2:19 PM EDT
4 months ago
Step 04
Generating AI Summary...
Analyzing up to 500 comments to identify key contributors and discussion patterns
ID: 45089154Type: storyLast synced: 11/20/2025, 8:56:45 PM
Want the full context?
Jump to the original sources
Read the primary article or dive into the live Hacker News thread when you're ready.
I can see why it might be best to exclude transgender women from most disciplines, at least untill we have more science about whether they have any advantage in them, but as a whole this debacle just feels silly.
The rationale for the female category is to remove this male advantage from competition. Allowing a subset of males who have the advantage of their sex to compete against female athletes, just because these males call themselves women, undermines the whole point of women's sport.
This is why we need such testing as described in the article. It's no different in principle to, for example, weigh-ins in boxing that enable fair competition in each weight category.
This is a line at which we ban accounts (https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...), so please stop doing this.
Also, please don't create accounts to do this with. It's not what the site is for, and destroys what it is for.
Take that and then consider that this goes even harder for people whose bodies never masculinized due to androgen insensitivity or whatever. Maybe it still carries some advantage, but... so what? So does pretty much every single gene variant top athletes have and nobody is trying to single those out.
I don't think people should be challenging these rules on human rights grounds. Of course it is devastating to individuals when they get barred. They got to where they are through a mix of genes and hard work. Now one thing about them that they might not even have known about is going to end their career. But elite sports is for entertainment. It is full of arbitrary rules, and there's plenty of life outside. Most people don't get to assert their womanhood at olympics.